Best Wood Pellets for Smoking

Jason Webster
Written by
Last update:

If you’re interested in starting to smoke your food for that delicious smoked flavor, you’re in luck. Nowadays, you can easily purchase wood pellets for your indoor electric smoker.

So, what’s the difference between different types of wood pellets? What are you paying for exactly, and which one is the best for your budget?

The following review will answer these questions and cover all the best types of wood pellets for smoking.

NameCategoryProduct
CookinPellets 40H Hickory Smoking PelletsBest OverallCookinPellets 40H Hickory Smoking Pellets
5 Gallon White Bucket & LidBudget Pick5 Gallon White Bucket & Lid
BBQrs Delight Wood Smoking PelletsUpgrade PickBBQrs Delight Wood Smoking Pellets

1. CookinPellets 40H Hickory Smoking Pellets

Our rating: 9 / 10

CookinPellets 40H Hickory Smoking Pellets

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Ready to use
  • Made with American white oak hardwood
  • Contains approx. 1,500 calories to use in one cook
  • These pellets produce a long-lasting smoke
  • Produces an ideal heat index
  • Available in other flavors
  • Produced by a USA-based company
  • One of the better pellet brands available on the market
  • A trusted brand with a great customer base
  • Long-lasting and ready to use

Cons:

  • Some pellet brands create burn-off that can be difficult to remove
  • Pellets can be a little difficult to light
  • Some pellet brands leave an aftertaste in your food
  • It takes some time for the pellets to get to heat up properly
  • You might have to play with the lighting a few times to get it right

A great pellet brand is a must in order for the average Pellet Smoker to get the best results. The good news for you is that CookinPellets is such a brand. You can rest assured that you won’t be let down by their high-quality hickory smoking pellets.

2. CookinPellets 40PM Perfect Mix

Our rating: 9 / 10

CookinPellets 40PM Perfect Mix

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Even heat and low ash
  • High quality and fast shipping
  • Makes delicious smoking wood pellets
  • These are wood pellets, not compressed sawdust
  • Excellent price
  • The perfect mix for all outdoor grills

Cons:

  • Pellets are a tad bit expensive
  • If you are not a pro, chances are you won’t get the most out of them

These pellets provide even heat and are easy to use in an outdoor pellet smoker. We’ve realized that most people who have an outdoor grill and a barbecue smoker are usually splitting their time evenly between both, so it’s important not to get the smoke flavors mixed up.

They’re not all created equal. Using the wrong wood pellets in a smoker could have major consequences. You could end up ruining one of the foods you are cooking, or adverse reactions from the smoke. The best smoking wood pellets are key to the best smoking experience.

The right pellets maintain temperature and make sure your smoke chamber is clean.

3. BBQrs Delight Wood Smoking Pellets

Our rating: 8 / 10

BBQrs Delight Wood Smoking Pellets

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Odorless and smokeless
  • They can be used for many things besides smoking
  • Different flavors may be used individually or in combination when smoking
  • Packaged in a resealable plastic container for easy storage
  • These are eco-friendly

Cons:

  • May be smaller than expected
  • For use in wood pellet smokers only

The BBQrs Delight pellets are the perfect choice if you are looking for something to smoke your food with that is small in size yet mighty in its ability to flavor your meat. They are not the cheapest option out there but worth it for any smoker alike.

You can use these pellets for smoking, roasting, and BBQing. Also, you can mix and match and use them separately even though they are a little smaller and runny than mixed wood chips. You can make your own flavoring combinations by mixing the different flavors you want.

We love the resealable container that they come in, as it allows us to store the rest of our pellets in a dry place until we need them to smoke food. This is a great traveling companion for any smoker.

4. 5 Gallon White Bucket & Lid

Our rating: 8 / 10

5 Gallon White Bucket & Lid

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • The lid comes with a shipping tape making it easy to seal
  • It’s durable
  • They are lightweight and compact so you can move them around with ease
  • You can store different stuff in them

Cons:

  • The lids don’t seal perfectly
  • You have to be very careful when handling
  • The lids aren’t watertight

The 5 Gallon White Bucket & Lid is a compact and handy storage container suitable for many different types of storage. It’s quite durable, and on top of that, it can be stacked together with other buckets when empty. The quality of the plastic material is also very good, you can be sure it won’t crack or leak any harmful substances if you accidentally drop it on a hard floor.

Another thing we really liked about this bucket were its price and versatility. You can use it as a dry food container, grains container, office organizer, storage box for arts and crafts, and even as a drum for kick starting a fire.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Who makes the best wood pellets for smoking?

When looking for the best pellets for smoking keep an eye out for a company that produces high quality and consistent finished pellets with no loose sawdust. This will ensure your pellets are produced as they should be and provide an even, clean burn in your smoker.

You should also make sure the pellets you buy are suitable for your smoker and are within the recommended loading range. This will prevent any jams during the smoking process.

In order to get consistent burns with your smoker, you also need to use quality pellets. Cheaper pellets burn hotter and burn quicker, giving a rasher burn to your meats. Our choice pellets are from a company called Sugaree. It’s made up of 100% hardwoods such as hickory, cherry, maple, almond, oak and mesquite. Your meats will come out much smokey, woody and delicious.

Which wood is best for smoking?

Different types of woods are used for smoking various meats and fishes. Many of these woods will give your meat a distinct and unique flavor while others will continue to flavor your meat for a long period of time.

Can you use wood pellets in a smoker?

You certainly can, IF the smoker is set up to handle wood pellets. There are some that are exclusive for wood pellet smoking only. If you are using wood pellets for the first time, you may want to make sure that your smoker can use this fuel before hand. Wood pellets are a cleaner and more efficient fuel source than wood. Remember to not soak the pellets because they will go into the pit and cause a mess.

When you are using wood pellets, you simply need to have a separate hopper for the pellets and then load them into the feeder. Depending on the type of wood pellet smoker you have, you may have an automatic feeder so you can focus your attention on the smoker, rather than having to pay attention to manually feeding the hopper.

What wood pellets are best for pizza?

These are heavier woods that are great for cooking pizzas in your smoker as they offer a longer smoke providing a more intense smoky flavor. They also give great color to the crust.

Hickory, Apple or Mesquite.

These woods are lighter and more suitable for flavoring the crust, other toppings and achieving the sweet flavor smoke ring that people expect from their pizza.

A mixture of woods can be used. Most people use 100% hickory for their base and then use a bit of apple wood or mesquite for the crust.

Conclusion

This buying guide will examine the factors that wood pellet buyers should consider before deciding on a brand of wood pellet. After all, not all wood pellets are created equal. And not all wood pellet smokers are the same either. We’ve discovered the best wood pellet smoker is one that’s compatible with many pellet brands and types of wood pellets to get the best results from your smoker and your favorite wood pellets.

Our Recommendation

NameCategoryProduct
CookinPellets 40H Hickory Smoking PelletsBest OverallCookinPellets 40H Hickory Smoking Pellets
5 Gallon White Bucket & LidBudget Pick5 Gallon White Bucket & Lid
BBQrs Delight Wood Smoking PelletsUpgrade PickBBQrs Delight Wood Smoking Pellets